Comotomo Bottle Review
The squishy silicone bottle that breastfed babies actually accept.
⚡ Quick Answer
Comotomo bottles are excellent for babies transitioning between breast and bottle. The soft silicone body mimics the feel of skin, and the naturally-shaped nipple reduces rejection. At ~$12 per bottle, they're pricier than standard options but worth it if nipple confusion is a concern. They're less ideal for exclusive formula feeders due to the slower flow.
Why dads love the Comotomo
When mom goes back to work or you're doing night feeds, the last thing you need is a baby who screams at the sight of a bottle. Comotomo's soft silicone body feels more natural in baby's hands (and mouth), and the wide-mound nipple shape is closer to breast anatomy than traditional bottles. Many lactation consultants recommend them specifically for breast-to-bottle transitions.
The flow rate situation
Here's where it gets nuanced. The 5oz bottle comes with slow-flow nipples designed for 0-3 months, and the 8oz comes with medium flow for 3-6 months. Multiple Reddit parents report the flow is genuinely slow — some newborns get frustrated. If your baby is exclusively formula-fed and a hungry eater, you might need to size up nipples faster than the age recommendations suggest.
Cleaning and durability
The wide neck is a game-changer for cleaning — you can actually fit your hand inside. Only 4 parts total (body, nipple, ring, cap), so assembly is dead simple at 3 AM. The silicone body is durable but can develop a sticky texture over time. They're dishwasher safe (top rack) and microwave sterilizer compatible. One complaint: the dual anti-colic vents can trap milk residue if you don't dry them thoroughly.
Comotomo vs Dr. Brown's vs Philips Avent
Dr. Brown's has better anti-colic performance but more parts to clean. Philips Avent has faster flow options and is cheaper. Comotomo wins on breast-like feel and simplicity. If preventing nipple confusion is priority #1, go Comotomo. If colic/gas is your main issue, go Dr. Brown's.
Pros & Cons
What We Like
- ✅ Soft silicone mimics breast feel — great for transitions
- ✅ Wide neck makes cleaning easy
- ✅ Only 4 parts — simple assembly
- ✅ Dual anti-colic vents
- ✅ BPA-free, PVC-free, phthalate-free
What Could Be Better
- ❌ Pricey at ~$12 per bottle
- ❌ Slow flow frustrates some hungry newborns
- ❌ Silicone gets sticky over time
- ❌ Anti-colic vents can trap residue
- ❌ Not ideal for exclusive formula feeders who need faster flow
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Are Comotomo bottles good for newborns?
Yes, particularly for breastfed newborns transitioning to bottle. The slow-flow nipple and breast-like shape reduce nipple confusion. Some very hungry newborns may find the flow too slow.
How often should you replace Comotomo bottles?
Replace nipples every 2-3 months or if they show signs of wear. The silicone body lasts much longer — typically 6-12 months of regular use.
Can you warm Comotomo bottles?
Yes. Use a bottle warmer or warm water bath. The silicone body heats evenly but can feel hot on the outside before the milk inside is warm — always test the milk temperature.
🏆 The Verdict
Comotomo bottles are the best choice for dads doing bottle feeds with a breastfed baby. The breast-like design genuinely reduces rejection, and the simple construction makes 3 AM feeds less painful. Not the best for exclusive formula feeding due to slower flow, but for mixed feeding families, they're worth every penny.
Check Price on Amazon📬 Get Dad-Tested Picks in Your Inbox
Weekly gear reviews, deals, and tips. No spam — just stuff that actually helps.
📋 Or grab our free Dad's Registry Checklist →