Philips Avent vs MAM Bottles
Two of the best anti-colic bottles for breastfed babies, compared head-to-head. Which one makes the breast-to-bottle transition smoother? Real dad opinions inside.
⚡ Quick Verdict
Get Philips Avent Natural if:
- • You want a breast-shaped nipple for easy latch
- • Wide neck for easy cleaning matters to you
- • You prefer a well-known, widely available brand
- • You want Natural Response flow technology
Get MAM Easy Start if:
- • You're switching a breastfed baby to bottles
- • Anti-colic performance is your top priority
- • You want self-sterilizing convenience
- • Your baby is picky about nipple texture
💡 Pro tip: MAM's SkinSoft silicone nipple has a 94% acceptance rate among breastfed babies in clinical studies. If nipple confusion is your biggest worry, MAM is the safer bet.
What Real Parents Are Saying
On Philips Avent Natural:
"The wide neck makes cleaning so much easier than narrow bottles. I can actually get a sponge inside without a special brush."— r/NewParents
"My daughter took to the Avent Natural right away. The breast shape really does help with latching. Only complaint is the anti-colic valve can leak if you don't assemble it perfectly."— r/breastfeeding
On MAM Easy Start:
"Game changer for our breastfed baby who refused every other bottle. The SkinSoft nipple was the only one she'd accept. Worth every penny."— r/beyondthebump
"Love the self-sterilizing feature. Three minutes in the microwave and you're done. No separate sterilizer needed."— r/Parenting
🍼 Nipple Design: The Most Important Factor
For breastfed babies, the nipple is everything. A bottle nipple that doesn't feel right will get rejected—and you'll be stuck with a screaming baby and a full bottle. Here's how these two compare:
Philips Avent Natural Nipple
- ✅ Breast-shaped design mimics mom's shape
- ✅ Natural Response technology releases milk when baby actively drinks
- ✅ Comfort petals flex for natural latch
- ✅ Wide base encourages wide-mouth latch
- ⚠️ Standard silicone texture (not skin-like)
MAM SkinSoft Nipple
- ✅ SkinSoft silicone mimics the feel of skin
- ✅ 94% acceptance rate in clinical studies
- ✅ Flat, symmetric shape works in any position
- ✅ Textured surface for familiar feel
- ⚠️ Symmetric shape differs from breast shape
💨 Anti-Colic Performance
Both bottles feature anti-colic systems, but they work differently:
| Factor | Philips Avent Natural | MAM Easy Start |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-colic system | AirFree vent (sold separately) | Vented base (built-in) |
| How it works | Valve in nipple reduces air intake | Base vents allow air in, not into milk |
| Extra parts needed | AirFree vent recommended | None (all included) |
| Effectiveness | Good | Excellent |
| Leak potential | Low-moderate | Low |
📊 Full Comparison
| Feature | Philips Avent Natural | MAM Easy Start |
|---|---|---|
| Nipple material | Silicone | SkinSoft silicone |
| Nipple shape | Breast-shaped | Wide, symmetric |
| Anti-colic | Yes (valve) | Yes (vented base) |
| Flow options | Slow, medium, fast | Slow, medium, fast |
| Self-sterilizing | No | Yes (3 min microwave) |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes | Yes |
| BPA-free | Yes | Yes |
| Wide neck | Yes | Yes |
| Price (4-pack) | ~$22-28 | ~$28-35 |
🧼 Cleaning & Maintenance: A Dad's Perspective
Let's be honest—you're going to be washing these bottles at 2 AM while half asleep. How easy they are to clean matters more than you think.
Philips Avent Cleaning
- ✅ Wide neck = easy to clean by hand
- ✅ Only 4 parts to assemble
- ✅ Dishwasher safe (top rack)
- ⚠️ Anti-colic valve can trap residue
- ⚠️ Requires separate sterilizer
MAM Cleaning
- ✅ Self-sterilizing in microwave (3 min)
- ✅ Base unscrews for thorough cleaning
- ✅ Dishwasher safe
- ⚠️ More parts (base separates)
- ⚠️ Small vent holes need attention
👍 Pros & Cons
Philips Avent Natural
Pros
- ✅ Breast-shaped nipple promotes natural latch
- ✅ Wide neck for easy cleaning
- ✅ Natural Response nipple adjusts to baby's pace
- ✅ More affordable price point
- ✅ Good variety of flow rates and accessories
Cons
- ❌ Can be tricky to assemble correctly
- ❌ Nipples may collapse if not paced properly
- ❌ AirFree vent sold separately
MAM Easy Start
Pros
- ✅ SkinSoft silicone feels like skin (94% acceptance)
- ✅ Self-sterilizing in microwave (3 minutes)
- ✅ Excellent built-in anti-colic system
- ✅ Best option for breast-to-bottle transition
- ✅ Symmetric nipple works in any position
Cons
- ❌ More expensive per bottle
- ❌ Fewer accessories available than Avent
- ❌ More parts to clean (separating base)
🤱 Tips for Breast-to-Bottle Transition
As dads, we're often the ones doing the first bottle feed. Here's what worked for us:
- 1. Wait until breastfeeding is established — Most lactation consultants recommend waiting 3-4 weeks before introducing a bottle.
- 2. Let dad do the first bottle feed — Baby associates mom with breastfeeding. A different person offering the bottle reduces confusion.
- 3. Use the slowest flow nipple — Both Avent and MAM offer slow-flow options. Start there to prevent flow preference.
- 4. Try paced bottle feeding — Hold the bottle horizontally and let baby control the pace, mimicking breastfeeding rhythm.
- 5. Warm the nipple first — Run the nipple under warm water before feeding. A cold silicone nipple feels nothing like mom.
- 6. Don't give up after one try — It can take 5-10 attempts before a breastfed baby accepts a bottle. Patience is key.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Which bottle is better for colic?
MAM Easy Start's vented base design is generally considered more effective at reducing colic symptoms. The air enters through the base rather than mixing with milk, which means less gas for baby. Philips Avent's AirFree vent (sold separately) can match this performance but adds cost.
Can I mix and match nipples between brands?
No. Philips Avent and MAM nipples are not interchangeable. Each brand's nipples are designed specifically for their bottles' threading and anti-colic systems. Using the wrong nipple can cause leaks and reduce anti-colic effectiveness.
How often should I replace bottle nipples?
Both brands recommend replacing nipples every 1-2 months, or sooner if you notice discoloration, thinning, or tears. A good rule: if the nipple feels sticky or looks cloudy after washing, it's time for a new one.
My breastfed baby refuses all bottles. What should I try?
MAM bottles have the highest acceptance rate among breastfed babies (94% in clinical studies). If your baby still refuses, try different feeding positions, have someone other than mom offer the bottle, warm the nipple under running water, and try during a calm (not starving) moment. Some babies do better with a cup or syringe if bottles are consistently refused.
Are these bottles compatible with breast pumps?
Philips Avent Natural bottles are directly compatible with Philips Avent breast pumps. MAM bottles are not directly compatible with most breast pumps, so you'll need to pump into a different container and transfer. This is one area where Avent has a clear advantage.
🏆 Final Verdict
Here's the dad truth: Both are excellent bottles, but they solve different problems.
- • If your breastfed baby refuses bottles → MAM Easy Start (highest acceptance rate)
- • If you want easy cleaning and pump compatibility → Philips Avent Natural
- • If colic is your biggest concern → MAM Easy Start (better anti-colic design)
- • If budget matters → Philips Avent Natural (more affordable)
- • If you use a Philips breast pump → Philips Avent Natural (direct compatibility)
Our overall pick for breastfed babies: MAM Easy Start. The SkinSoft nipple's acceptance rate is hard to argue with when nipple confusion is the primary concern.
Related Articles
Affiliate Disclosure
DadChoice.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in.