Dekor Plus vs Ubbi Diaper Pail
Two premium diaper pails compared head-to-head. Which one actually keeps the smell contained? Real dad opinions inside.
⚡ Quick Verdict
Get Dekor Plus if:
- • Long-term refill cost matters most
- • You want hands-free step-to-open
- • Eco-friendliness is important (70% recycled)
- • You use cloth diapers
Get Ubbi if:
- • Odor control is your #1 concern
- • You want to use regular trash bags
- • Nursery aesthetics matter to you
- • You prefer steel over plastic
💡 Pro tip: The Ubbi's steel construction is genuinely better at containing odors than plastic. If smell is your biggest worry (and let's be honest, it should be), the Ubbi has the edge.
What Real Parents Are Saying
On Dekor Plus:
"The continuous liner system is genius. You just cut and tie—no fumbling with individual bags. Refills last forever compared to Diaper Genie."— r/daddit
"After a year the plastic started absorbing odors. Even empty, the pail smells. Baking soda helps but it's not perfect. Considering switching to the Ubbi."— r/beyondthebump
On Ubbi:
"The steel construction is the real deal. Two years in and zero lingering odors. When the lid is closed, you'd never know there are 40 dirty diapers inside."— r/NewParents
"Love that I can use any trash bag. Kitchen bags work perfectly. No proprietary refill nonsense. The pail itself looks great in the nursery too."— r/Parenting
👃 Odor Control: The Only Thing That Really Matters
Let's be real—the entire point of a diaper pail is containing the smell. Everything else is secondary. Here's how each one handles the stink:
Dekor Plus Odor Control
- ✅ Multi-layer refill film traps odors
- ✅ Powder-scented refills available
- ✅ Trap door minimizes air exchange
- ⚠️ Plastic absorbs odors over time (6-12 months)
- ⚠️ Opening the lid releases more smell than Ubbi
Ubbi Odor Control
- ✅ Steel construction doesn't absorb odors
- ✅ Rubber gaskets create airtight seal
- ✅ Sliding lid minimizes air exchange
- ✅ Still odor-free after years of use
- ⚠️ Sliding lid lets out a brief puff when opened
💰 Long-Term Cost: The Hidden Expense
The pail itself is just the upfront cost. Refill bags are the ongoing expense that adds up:
| Cost Factor | Dekor Plus | Ubbi |
|---|---|---|
| Pail price | ~$40-50 | ~$60-80 |
| Refill type | Continuous liner (proprietary) | Any standard trash bag |
| Refill cost (per year) | ~$40-50 | ~$20-30 (regular bags) |
| 2-year total cost | ~$120-150 | ~$100-140 |
| Bag change frequency | Every ~46 diapers | Every ~55 diapers |
💡 The real savings: The Ubbi accepts any 13-gallon kitchen trash bag. You're never locked into proprietary refills. Over 2+ years of diapering, this flexibility saves real money.
📊 Full Comparison
| Feature | Dekor Plus | Ubbi |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Plastic (70% recycled) | Steel |
| Capacity | ~46 newborn diapers | ~55 newborn diapers |
| Opening mechanism | Foot pedal (hands-free) | Sliding lid (one hand) |
| Bag type | Continuous liner | Any trash bag |
| Odor control | Good (degrades over time) | Excellent (steel + rubber gaskets) |
| Cloth diaper compatible | Yes | Yes |
| Eco-friendly | Yes (70% recycled plastic) | Moderate (steel is recyclable) |
| Child lock | No | Yes |
| Color options | Limited | 12+ colors |
| Price | ~$40-50 | ~$60-80 |
🔧 Daily Use: A Dad's Perspective
You'll use this thing 8-12 times a day. Here's what the daily experience is actually like:
- Hands-free operation: The Dekor's foot pedal is genuinely hands-free—step on it, drop the diaper, done. The Ubbi's sliding lid needs one hand, which means you're holding the baby with the other. Both work, but the Dekor is slightly easier mid-diaper-change.
- Bag changes: The Dekor's continuous liner takes about 20 seconds to change—pull, cut, tie, done. The Ubbi uses regular trash bags, which is familiar and fast. Neither is difficult.
- Toddler-proofing: The Ubbi's child lock is a nice touch once your kid becomes mobile. The Dekor has no child lock, and curious toddlers can figure out the foot pedal pretty quickly.
- Nursery aesthetics: The Ubbi's steel construction and 12+ color options make it look like actual furniture, not a trash can. The Dekor looks like... a plastic diaper pail. If nursery design matters to you, Ubbi wins easily.
- Longevity: After 18+ months, the Ubbi still performs like new. Plastic pails (including the Dekor) tend to absorb odors permanently over time. This is the biggest long-term difference.
👍 Pros & Cons
Dekor Plus
Pros
- ✅ Hands-free foot pedal operation
- ✅ Economical continuous liner system
- ✅ Eco-friendly (70% recycled materials)
- ✅ Easy 20-second bag changes
- ✅ Lower upfront cost
Cons
- ❌ Plastic absorbs odors over time
- ❌ Less premium appearance
- ❌ No child lock
Ubbi
Pros
- ✅ Steel construction locks in odors permanently
- ✅ Accepts any standard trash bag
- ✅ Modern design with 12+ color options
- ✅ Higher capacity (55 diapers)
- ✅ Built-in child lock
Cons
- ❌ Higher upfront cost
- ❌ Sliding lid requires one hand
- ❌ Heavier than the Dekor Plus
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Do I even need a diaper pail?
You could use a regular trash can with a lid, but you'll regret it within a week. Diaper pails are specifically designed to contain odors, and the difference is dramatic. Trust us—your nose (and your guests) will thank you.
Can I use regular trash bags in the Dekor Plus?
Not easily. The Dekor is designed for its proprietary continuous liner system. Some parents hack it with regular bags, but it's awkward and reduces odor control. The Ubbi is the better choice if you want to use standard bags.
How often do I need to empty these?
For newborns (10-12 diapers/day), the Dekor holds about 4 days' worth and the Ubbi about 5 days'. As your baby gets older and diaper changes decrease, they last even longer. We recommend emptying every 3-4 days regardless for maximum freshness.
Which is better for cloth diapers?
Both work with cloth diapers, but the Ubbi's steel construction has an advantage—it won't absorb odors from wet cloth diapers sitting between wash days. The Dekor's plastic will eventually take on that smell permanently.
What about the Diaper Genie? How do these compare?
Both the Dekor Plus and Ubbi outperform the Diaper Genie in odor control and long-term cost. The Diaper Genie's refills are the most expensive of the three, and its plastic construction has the same odor-absorption problem as the Dekor. If you're choosing between all three, the Ubbi offers the best overall value.
🏆 Final Verdict
Here's the dad truth: The Ubbi is the better diaper pail for most families.
- • If odor control is king (it should be) → Ubbi
- • If you want hands-free operation → Dekor Plus
- • If nursery aesthetics matter → Ubbi
- • If you're eco-conscious → Dekor Plus
- • If you refuse proprietary refills → Ubbi
- • If upfront budget is tight → Dekor Plus
Our overall pick: Ubbi. The steel construction, standard trash bag compatibility, child lock, and superior long-term odor control make it the smarter investment. The higher upfront cost pays for itself in bag savings and odor-free years.
Related Articles
Affiliate Disclosure
DadChoice.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in.